Total return ignores when the money went in
Total return compares what you put in with what it is worth now: gain ÷ amount invested. It is a fair number for one lump sum held for one known period. With a SIP, the money goes in a little at a time, so most of it has been invested for much less time than the first instalment.
Invented example: ₹10,000 a month for 12 months is ₹1,20,000 put in. If it is worth ₹1,30,000 one month after the last instalment, the total return is 8.33%. But the money was invested for only about 6.5 months on average, so as a yearly rate it is about 15.7%.
What XIRR adds
XIRR is a yearly rate that counts the date and amount of every investment and every withdrawal. It answers: what single yearly rate would turn these exact payments, on these exact dates, into today’s value? That puts SIPs, lump sums and withdrawals on one footing.
It can also make a short period look extreme. A small gain over a few weeks becomes a large yearly rate, which is why the X-ray does not show a yearly return for money held less than a year.
What the X-ray’s number counts
The Portfolio X-ray reads your CAMS or KFintech statement and uses every purchase, SIP instalment, switch and redemption it lists, from your first investment to the statement date, with the fund’s value on that date. The result is your yearly return so far.
It is a fact about the past. It does not say what your funds will earn next, and it is before income tax on any gains.