Skip to content
Arthvyuh

Reality Check

What really happened to money in a Nifty 50 index fund, and to people who traded futures and options. Real past numbers.

Free. No sign-up. Nothing to buy.

  1. Two ways to use the same money
  2. How many trades you must win
  3. What charges cost in a year
Index fund
A fund that holds the shares of India's 50 largest listed companies (the Nifty 50). People usually keep it for years.
Futures and options (F&O)
Short-term contracts whose value moves with the market. They are traded over days or weeks, often for a small upfront amount that controls a much bigger position.

Two ways to use the same money

₹1,00,000
5 years
How the money goes in

This assumes money you will not need for these years. It is an illustration, not a plan for you. These choices change only the index fund result.

Way 1: one index fund

Money put in a Nifty 50 index fund

–

Loading the fund's past prices…

What this means: what this real index fund did in the past. The future can be different.

Lowest result
–
Middle result (half did better, half worse)
–
Highest result
–
Yearly growth in the middle past period (not a forecast)
–

Past performance may or may not be sustained in the future. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks; read all scheme-related documents carefully. Results are before income tax and exit load; tax on gains would reduce them.

Where these numbers come from

We show one index fund only because its full price history is public. It is an example, not a suggestion. Other index funds exist and their results differ.

Source: AMFI month-end NAV (the fund's published price) of UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund (Direct, Growth).

Index data up to 30 Oct 2026

Way 2: everyone who traded F&O

Trading futures and options (F&O)

87.7% lost money

of individual F&O traders in FY26 (April 2025 to March 2026), after costs.

Lost money (88) Did not (12). Each dot is 1 trader in 100.

What this means: this is SEBI's count for everyone who traded in one year. It is not your result, and we do not guess what you would lose.

  • Before costs, 82 of 100 lost money. After costs, 88 of 100.
  • Average result per trader, all traders: a loss of ₹1.17 lakh. A smaller group with very large losses pulls this up: about 23% of traders made nearly 90% of all losses.
  • Average loss of those who lost: ₹1.47 lakh.
  • Costs were 35% of these traders' losses before costs.
  • About 9 in 10 lost money in each year from FY22 to FY25 too (90.2% to 91.5%).
Where these numbers come from

Source: SEBI, Profitability of Individual Traders in the Equity Derivatives Segment (FY25-FY26), August 2026. Individuals include retail and HNI traders, HUFs, NRIs and PMS clients; SEBI used broker data covering about 90% of them. Figures are SEBI's; we did not change them.

These are different kinds of numbers. Way 1 is one fund's price history over the time you choose. Way 2 is one year's result for everyone who traded. Neither is a prediction for you. An index fund can also fall, especially over short periods (try 1 year).

How many trades must you win just to not lose money?

A trade is one buy and one sell. Some trades win, some lose. Type what a usual winning trade makes and what a usual losing trade loses, before charges.

How we worked this out

Formula: (loss + charges) ÷ (win + loss). Charges use rates in force from 1 April 2026: about ₹63 for one buy and one sell of 1 NIFTY lot (65 units) at a ₹100 option price. That is ₹40 brokerage (₹20 per order; your broker may charge differently) plus ₹22.63 of STT, exchange fee, SEBI fee, stamp duty and 18% GST. Charges change with the option price and the number of lots: edit the box for your case. Slippage and income tax are not included, so the real figure is higher. The win and loss values are examples only.

Share of trades you must win

–

What this means: you must win this many of every 100 trades just to not lose money.

What charges cost in a year

3

Each is one buy and one sell of 1 lot.

Trades a day × charges for one trade (from part 2) × 250 trading days. This is an illustration with the charges from part 2 (1 lot at a ₹100 option price). Your own trades will cost more or less.

Charges in one year

–

What this means: charges paid to your broker, the exchange and the government in one year, before any profit or loss.

Want to understand the basics first?

Arthvyuh is a software tool for building and testing your own rules on past data. It does not tell you what to trade, and there is nothing you need to do today.

Illustration of past data. Not investment advice. We never tell you what to buy or sell. Arthvyuh is not connected with SEBI, AMFI or any fund house. Read the risk disclosure.